This blog is designed to capture the research efforts of students involved in the CGIS-FMSO fellowship.
Monday, February 27, 2012
Chinese Commentaries on International Affairs (February 20-February 26)
Friday, February 24, 2012
Security Forces: What's happening now?
Security policy analysts often suggest that Rio’s several police forces reform and unify into one large force. According to one public safety specialist, this is not a feasible option since each force has a specific function. Brazil’s Public Safety Secretary explains: “We inherited [the division between civil, investigative police and military, enforcement police] from the times of the [Portuguese] empire. You can’t decree things. Today, as Secretary, I think we’re still very far from having a police force with the whole cycle, from investigation to patrolling.”
There are around five hundred new police officers entering the force each month. The new officers are being trained under a new mentality, one which aims at de-emphasizing the importance of killing; one where police offers don’t feel naked without a rifle. As the curriculum changes and Rio’s favelas undergo their makeovers, one wonders if now would be the best time to transform the police forces into one, and if so, what this would look like? One thing is clear; in order to be effective, officials will need to maintain a constant community presence that is focused on prevention and respects human rights. The use of highly visible, forceful and ‘military style’ executions are becoming less and less popular (Michaels).
The UPPs (Pacifying Police Divisions) are squadrons of Brazilian officers occupying favelas using community-policing methods. The drug gangs and traffickers, who often have been in control of the favelas for over three decades, certainly feel the pressure on themselves and on their profits. Reflecting on the seriousness of the invasions, Beltrame stated (in somewhat war-like language), "We have taken from these people what was never taken from them before — their territory. They commit their barbarous acts, and they run for their hideouts, protected by weapons of war. It's important to arrest them, but it is more important to occupy their territory. Without seizing territory, there is no advance."
There have been 17 UPPs set up in 68 favelas, and crimes (such as murder and assault) in those communities are down significantly. To understand the implications of the UPPs will take a much deeper analysis, which will be addressed later on with the help of community (favela) level testimonies. However, it is clear that the policies for favela integration and restructuring must be long-term, and that they will require more than just community policing, and will need the support of international organizations and local NGOs.
Downie, Andrew. “Rio Finally Makes Headway Against its Drug Gangs.” Time Magazine. 11/26/2010.
Croiz, Sarah de Sainte. “Police Strike in Rio Begins Today: Daily” Rio Times. 2/10/2012.
Michaels, Julia. “Rio's top cop talks public safety policy, favela pacification program.” Latin America Monitor. 10/20/2011.
Sunday, February 19, 2012
Xi's Trip to the US and Other Commentaries
Monday, February 13, 2012
Chinese Commentaries on International Affairs (February 6-February 12)
Sunday, February 5, 2012
Chinese Commentaries on International Affairs (January 30-February 5)
Thursday, February 2, 2012
A Comparative Look at Goals and Security Systems
Mega-events are not only reporting on sports, but they are providing the world with coverage of the host country. In the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the government saw it as an opportunity to legitimatize the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and depict itself as a modernized society. In the 2010 South Africa World Cup, the government would saw it as an opportunity to legitimize itself by showing that Africa can manage large and complicated projects and is ready to be a player in the global economy. Brazil, however, has already been legitimized as an economic and political power. As one of the few countries in the world to have a female president, the events offer Brazil the opportunity to solidify its role as a major global political and economic influence. Security will be the biggest barrier to this.
The post 9/11 panic mentality in the international community has generated high international security concerns for any mega-event. Western security systems and US corporations play a large role in these issues. The mega-events have created global security market for new monitoring technologies, a market that the US is actively involved in. Some fear that the ‘Olympic spirit’ has been replaced by greedy private businesses, and that these events have become testing-grounds for new security systems where the main corporate players benefit.
The Athens games in 2004 accepted direct US and international assistance. The American Science Application International Corporation (SAIC) helped to implement the C41 security system, and linked to a central command center that integrates all security forces and information. The command center crashed and became a technical nightmare. The flawed system remained useless. SAIC, which has close relationships with the Pentagon, had promoted the use of the C14 system for the Athens Olympics. Although the system crashed, Athens was still able to convey a perceived sense of security during the events. Visible airborne surveillance, although a controversial spectacle, offered comfort for all of the Olympic participants. It also kept any potential security threats ignorant of the system malfunctions.
More and more, cities are looking to the citizens for assistance. A special 100,000 person anti-terrorist force was organized for the China’s games in 2008. The force was backed by 400,000 city volunteers. The volunteer group was made up of taxi drivers, receptionists, and other members of the public. Because of this system, the Chinese forces had people reporting on every level. Security was linked with patriotism, and citizens took any potential threats to Chinese security personally. Vancouver and London have also promoted public awareness, and encouraged citizens on all levels to report suspicious behavior.
Electronic surveillance systems help track, target and profile suspects, control population, watch traffic and monitor electronic communication. Brazil will have the decision which system to implement and which countries to involve in the decision. Brazil security officials need to seek help and volunteers on every level, and make security concerns relevant to all people in Brazil. Make the public active participants in the security issues. The public might be able to identify security gaps that officials missed.
“Surveillance in Athens 2004 and Beijing 2008: A Comparison of the Olympic Surveillance Modalities and Legacies in Two Different Olympic Host Regimes.” Samatas, Minas. Oct. 24, 2011.
“Before and After the Vuvuzela: Identity, Image and Mega-Events in South Africa, China and Brazil.” Tomlinson, Richard. South African Geographical Journal. May 16, 2011.